Third Refection Essay

The Third Reflection Essay will be due on Tuesday 11/25 at 5 p.m. on your blog.

Focus in your writing on how politics relates to sustainability in The Lord of the Rings (Books 1-4) and on what kind of definition of sustainability politics helps to form in the story.  Politics involves a sense of what is a good community and how  communities organize themselves in relation to their natural, social, technological, and cultural environments. You may draw on ideas from David Bentley Hart’s reflection on Tolkien’s anarcho-monarchism, on our trip to the Constitution Center, and/or on other sources.  Develop in your first paragraph an enthymeme thesis, and a statement of significance, as we will workshop in our seminar together. You should focus in the body paragraphs on close readings of two passages from two separate chapters, at least one of which should be in Books 5 or 6. Each passage should be not longer than four pages long. The concluding paragraph should expand upon the statement of significance in your opening paragraph, as we will discuss in seminar. Please use at least three outside scholarly sources, not Wikpedia or .com sites, or dictionaries or encyclopedias. You may cite the Davis book, Dickerson & Evans, and the Bible, but these won’t count toward your three outside sources. You should weave into your close readings contexts from the social and natural environment of the text, as well as backgrounds from the author’s life, perspectives of readers then and now, and textual sources, as these are appropriate. In this you should draw on Timo Maran’s nature-text model and likewise on MNEMs, as models discussed in class for environmental reading.

Please use MLA style for citations and a Works Cited bibliography. The Works Cited bibliography should be in the same document, please don’t put it in a separate document. Please put page numbers in the upper right corner and do not use a separate cover sheet, the first page can begin with your name in the upper right corner and below it a centered title, and below that the start of the text.

The reflection should be 1,500 to 1,700 words in length, no longer or shorter.

We shal schedule preliminary meetings on the week of Nov. 10. By the time of our meeting, please send to me via email a short draft topic and thesis, and a short list of possible scholarly sources. This should take the form of a paragraph and three sources, including a draft enthymeme thesis. The email must be received with the completed assignment by the time of our meeting or 5 points will be subtracted from your essay grade, as this is part of the workshop process for this assignment.

Please double space the essay and write it in a Word document, which needs to be submitted as an email attachment, in an email in which you “cc” yourself to make sure that it has gone through and is openable. You are responsible for any technical problems, so please make sure that you allow enough time to accommodate any potential difficulties.

Late work will not be accepted without an official health or dean’s excuse. Please remember that you need to pass each major written assignment (each of the three reflections) in order to pass the course. If you receive a passing grade, you will also have the opportunity to revise it for a higher grade by the end of the seminar’s scheduled final exam, which is on Mon. Dec. 15, by 11 a.m. An excellent revision can garner additional points equal to one higher letter grade than the first version, but that depends on the quality of the work.

The essay will be graded approximately according to this rubric:

25 successful enthymeme thesis and statement of significance in an engaging and well-integrated opening paragraph

25 Effective framework of topic sentences for body paragraphs, related to the overall essay thesis and the conclusion

10 First close reading’s depth of analysis and detail

10 Second close reading’s depth of analysis and detial

10 Effective use of outside sources, citations and bibliography

10 Effective conclusion

10 Good editing and overall effective and graceful writing style

Please avoid trying to structure your paragraph in a “five-paragraph theme” style.

Enjoy your exploration of the topic!

Ithilien Queiz

1. Which statement is the most true (just list letter)

 

a. Gollum is glad to arrive at Ithilien only because he wants to hurry the group on his planned route.

b.. Gollum seems allergic to Ithilien.

c. Gollum wishes they had remained nearer to Mordor.

 

2. Two images stand out from Sam’s “first view of a battle of Men against Men.” Briefly list the two.

 

3. Who says that we most only love the sword and the warrior for “what they defend.”

 

4. Who “hungered after life unchanging” to corruption?

 

5. Who is described as reminding one of the characters of  “Gandalf, of wizards”?

 

quiz at isengard

1. Gandalf specifically diagnoses the cause of Saruman’s moral downfall in our reading for today. To what in particular does he attribute it there? (be very specific)

2. Pippin earlier said that Saruman’s great strategic mistake was to leave something out of his calculations (this was in terms of Saruman’s planning for war, not in terms of his moral downfall). What in particular is that which Pippin says Saruman left out of his calculations, resulting in his defeat?

3. In our reading for today the Huorns are described in a way more specifically than what we discussed about them in class Wednesday. What is the specific definition of the Huorns from today’s reading?

4. How many palantíri were there originally, according to the poem recited by Gandalf (“— stones”) and the list given in the narration?

5. Who originally used the stones as a communications network?

Second Reflection Essay

The Second Reflection Essay will be due on Saturday10/25 at 5 p.m.

Focus in your writing on how aesthetics relates to sustainability in the first two volumes of The Lord of the Rings (Books 1-4) and on what kind of definition of sustainability aesthetics helps to form in the story. Aesthetics involves a sense of what is beautiful and harmonious, and in environmental terms can also relate to different ecological cultures of landscape, as described in Dickerson & Evans. Develop in your first paragraph an enthymeme thesis, and a statement of significance, as we will workshop in our seminar together. You should focus in the body paragraphs on close readings of two passages from two separate chapters, at least one of which should be in Books 3 or 4. Each passage should be not longer than four pages long. The concluding paragraph should expand upon the statement of significance in your opening paragraph, as we will discuss in seminar. Please use at least three outside scholarly sources, not Wikpedia or .com sites, or dictionaries or encyclopedias. You may cite the Davis book, Dickerson & Evans, and the Bible, but these won’t count toward your three outside sources. You should weave into your close readings contexts from the social and natural environment of the text, as well as backgrounds from the author’s life, perspectives of readers then and now, and textual sources, as these are appropriate. In this you should draw on Timo Maran’s nature-text model and likewise on MNEMs, as models discussed in class for environmental reading.

Please use MLA style for citations and a Works Cited bibliography. The Works Cited bibliography should be in the same document, please don’t put it in a separate document. Please put page numbers in the upper right corner and do not use a separate cover sheet, the first page can begin with your name in the upper right corner and below it a centered title, and below that the start of the text.

The reflection should be 1,500 to 1,700 words in length, no longer or shorter.

For the week after Fall Break, by the time of our individual meeting that Thursday or Friday (which will be scheduled on a google.doc soon), please send to me via email a short draft topic and thesis, and a short list of possible scholarly sources. This should take the form of a paragraph and three sources, including a draft enthymeme thesis. The email must be received with the completed assignment by 8 a.m. Thurs. 8/16, or 5 points will be subtracted from your essay grade, as this is part of the workshop process for this assignment.

Please double space the essay and write it in a Word document, which needs to be submitted as an email attachment, in an email in which you “cc” yourself to make sure that it has gone through and is openable. You are responsible for any technical problems, so please make sure that you allow enough time to accommodate any potential difficulties.

Late work will not be accepted without an official health or dean’s excuse. Please remember that you need to pass each major written assignment (each of the three reflections) in order to pass the course. If you receive a passing grade, you will also have the opportunity to revise it for a higher grade by the end of the seminar’s scheduled final exam, which is on Mon. Dec. 15, by 11 a.m. An excellent revision can garner additional points equal to one higher letter grade than the first version, but that depends on the quality of the work.

The essay will be graded approximately according to this rubric:

25 successful enthymeme thesis and statement of significance in an engaging and well-integrated opening paragraph

25 Effective framework of topic sentences for body paragraphs, related to the overall essay thesis and the conclusion

10 First close reading’s depth of analysis and detail

10 Second close reading’s depth of analysis and detial

10 Effective use of outside sources, citations and bibliography

10 Effective conclusion

10 Good editing and overall effective and graceful writing style

Please avoid trying to structure your paragraph in a “five-paragraph theme” style.

Enjoy your exploration of the topic!